1979

  • Lee Mcllwain - Baseball
  • William Beckett - Baseball
  • Frank Lamanna - Baseball
  • Albert Ferrara - Track
  • Ronald Andreo - Football
  • Don Altman - Football
  • Eugene Sobolewski - Football
  • Special Award: Don Martin

1978

  • Lewis Hundermark - Baseball
  • Richard "Dick" Goldberg - Baseball
  • Roy "Katy" Easterday - Football Coach
  • John Moyer - Baseball
  • Woodrow White - Boxing
  • Michael Caruso - Football
  • John Sinclair - Basketball
  • Charles T. Hutchison - Basketball

1977

  • John Brochetti - Football
  • Charles F. "Chip" Young - Football
  • Charles Schmaus - Basketball
  • Fred Lynds - Football
  • Robert Pepper - Baseball
  • Charles Carci - Rifle
  • Lud Smith - Baseball
  • Steve Nickleach - Boxing
  • Albert Rinaldi - Football Coach
  • Thomas Piscolish - Baseball
  • Roy Vensel - Basketball
  • Frank Franceschi - Baseball

1976

  • Victor Klukan - Baseball
  • John "Smiley" Simmons - Basketball
  • Mike Cook - Baseball
  • Frank "Lefty" Barbero - Baseball
  • Frank H. "Abe" Shaffer - Baseball
  • Jackie Armitage - Boxing
  • Frederick "Fritz" Carpen - Baseball
  • Larry Karl - Sports Promoter
  • Dorothy Kovalchick Roark - Baseball
  • Mike Roebuck - Baseball
  • Benjamin W. Bowser - Sports Promoter
  • Domenic Garda, Sr. - Football
  • John Karrs - Football Coach
  • Fred H. Burdette - Baseball

1975

  • Charles A. "Chuck" Darr - Baseball
  • Ossee Freeman Schreckengost - Baseball
  • Ken E. Wolfe - Football Coach
  • Charles Canterna - Baseball
  • Robert W. Thurbon - Football Coach
  • John Manfredi - Baseball
  • Ellis R. McCracken - Football Coach
  • Albert "Shorty" Novak - Sports Official

1974

  • Dr. Paul Bayne - Baseball
  • Buggs Hershe - Baseball
  • Frederick L. Hill - Baseball
  • George Lindeman - Basketball
  • Roy Bowser - Harness Racing
  • Adam Gardina - Baseball
  • Dan Wright - Baseball
  • John "Bounce" Kovalchick - Baseball
  • Zigmund "Red" Mihalik - Basketball
  • John "Big Train" Moody - Football
  • William P. Canterna - Basketball
  • Edward Hobaugh - Baseball
  • Richard "Dick" Hunter - Football

1973

  • Clyde French - Baseball
  • James B. Patterson - Baseball
  • Ralph "Slim" Reisgen - Basketball
  • Henry "Hank" Sellers - Basketball
  • Arda C. Bowser - Football
  • Stanley McCollum - Football
  • Frank E. Butler - Sports Official
  • Jay D. Swigart - Boxing
  • Michael Dzvonik - Basketball
  • William E. Mitchell - Football & Basketball Coach
  • Odeal Pryor - Football
  • Robert Moody - Boxing
  • Greno "Hank" Buzzinotti - Baseball
  • Dom Canterna - Basketball
  • Hubert "Hube" Rupert - Basketball Coach
  • Jackie Wilson - Boxing
  • Leon "Bud" Carson - Football
  • A.W. "Tony" Senopole - Basketball
  • Ronald Shoop - Baseball

1972

  • Fred Boylestein - Boxing
  • Paul Bowser - Wrestling
  • Walter Bowser - Horse Racing
  • Robert Brodhead - Football
  • Cornelius “Nennie” Campbell - Basketball Coach
  • Isabelle H. Cechvala - Gymnastics
  • Charles “Toby” Fullerton - Baseball
  • Mike Goliat - Baseball
  • John Gurski - Football
  • Fritz Scheeren - Baseball
  • Edward McGivern - Baseball
  • Dr. Earl A. Rose - Basketball
  • Frank R. Swast - Sports Writer
  • John Souchock - Baseball
  • Steve Souchock - Baseball
  • Richard “Dick” Starr - Baseball
  • Oland “Dodo” Canterna - Basketball
  • Alex Kroll - Football
  • Robert “Bob” Pellegrini - Football
  • Clyde Fullerton - Baseball